ServicebuiltServiceBuilt home Start free

ServiceBuilt / Guides / Lead sources

Marketing and leads

Which garage door lead sources pay: LSA, Thumbtack, Angi and your website

Every garage door owner has a gut feeling about which lead source works. Most of those feelings are built on cost per lead, which is the one number that tells you almost nothing. Here is how to rank your sources by what they actually put in the bank, and what to do with the answer.

The short answer

The garage door lead sources that pay are the ones with the lowest cost per booked job and the most gross profit per dollar spent, not the cheapest leads. Tag every job with its source, then compare spend, booked jobs, average ticket and profit after ad spend for each one over two or three months. The answer is usually different from what the cost-per-lead report says.

When owners argue about garage door lead sources, the argument is usually about price per lead. One platform charges more per lead, another charges less, so the cheap one must be the better deal. That logic skips three steps: how many of those leads book, how many of the booked jobs turn into a real ticket, and how much of that ticket is profit once the springs and the door are paid for.

The four numbers that rank a lead source

You need four numbers per source per month. Everything else is decoration.

  1. Spend. Everything that source cost you: platform charges, monthly fees, the agency or tool you pay to run it. For your website, that means hosting, SEO and whatever you pay to keep it up.
  2. Booked jobs. Leads that turned into a job on the schedule. Not calls, not form fills, not "interested."
  3. Revenue from those jobs. What was actually invoiced, which also gives you the average ticket for that source.
  4. Gross profit from those jobs. Revenue minus parts cost. A $2,800 door install and a $2,800 day of repair work are not the same money.

From those you get the two numbers that matter: cost per booked job (spend divided by booked jobs) and profit after ad spend (gross profit minus spend). If you want one ratio to sort by, use gross profit per dollar spent.

Why cost per lead ranks garage door lead sources wrong

Here is a made-up month for a shop running four sources. The first table is the view most owners look at.

SourceSpendLeadsCost per leadBooked jobsCost per booked job
Google LSA$4,00080$5052$77
Thumbtack$1,50060$2518$83
Angi$1,20040$3010$120
Website and Google Business Profile$1,00045$2232$31
Month total$7,700225$34112$69

Illustrative numbers only, not benchmarks for any platform. Swap in your own month.

On cost per lead, LSA looks like the expensive one at twice the price of Thumbtack. On cost per booked job the two are nearly level, because more of the LSA leads booked. Angi, which looked middle of the pack per lead, is the most expensive way to put a job on the board.

Now carry the same booked jobs through to the money.

SourceBooked jobsAvg ticketGross profitProfit after ad spendGross profit per $1
Google LSA52$500$17,680$13,680$4.42
Thumbtack18$350$4,410$2,910$2.94
Angi10$380$2,508$1,308$2.09
Website and Google Business Profile32$700$13,440$12,440$13.44
Month total112$522$38,038$30,338$4.94

Illustrative numbers. Gross profit is revenue minus parts cost; parts share varies by source because the job mix varies.

In this example every source makes money, which is the first thing worth knowing. The second is the gap: the website returns more than three times what LSA does per dollar, and LSA returns about double Angi. The third is where the next dollar should go. Cutting the website budget to "save" $1,000 would be the worst move on the sheet, and pulling the Angi budget back to fund more of whatever books best is the obvious test.

Notice too that the average ticket moves by source. Customers who found you on your own site or map listing in this example bought more installs and bigger repairs. Whatever your real numbers show, the ticket by source is the part a cost-per-lead report never shows you.

What each source is actually selling you

Google Local Services Ads

Google says Local Services Ads charge for valid leads, not clicks. Its help page on how leads work lists answered calls, missed calls during business hours where the caller stays on more than 20 seconds, messages, voicemails and booking requests as leads that can be charged. Google also says charged leads it later judges low quality can be credited automatically, and that you can rate leads in the account.

Two practical points follow. A missed call can cost you, so your phone coverage is part of your LSA cost. And Google is moving Local Services Ads into Performance Max campaigns with pay-per-lead goals in phases starting in 2026, which changes how budgets and bidding are set. Google says reports from the old view do not carry over, so export your numbers before your account moves.

Thumbtack and Angi

Both sell you contact with a homeowner who asked for a service, and both have more than one program and pricing setup. Rather than trust anyone's summary, including this one, read the current terms on your own account: what you are charged for, when, whether the same request goes to other pros, and what you can get credited. Then let your booked-job numbers decide.

Your website and Google Business Profile

The cost is mostly fixed, so once it is producing it can look very cheap per booked job, and in the months before that it looks expensive. Count it honestly: hosting, SEO, the person who answers reviews. Then give it its own tracking number or form tag so its jobs do not get lumped in with "Google."

Repeat customers and referrals

These cost almost nothing to acquire, so they break the ratio. Track them as their own sources anyway. If repeat work is a shrinking share of your board, that is a customer-follow-up problem, not an advertising one.

How to tag every job with its source

None of this works if a third of your jobs say "unknown." Set it up once and enforce it.

  1. Pick a fixed list. Six to ten sources, spelled one way. "LSA," "Google LSA" and "Google ads" in the same report is three sources pretending to be one.
  2. Make the field required at booking. The source gets set when the job is created, by whoever books it, not filled in later from memory.
  3. Use a separate tracking number per paid source. Calls are tagged by the number they dialed, so the CSR does not have to guess.
  4. Ask anyway when you can't tell. "How did you find us today?" is a fine question, as long as the answer goes into the same fixed list.
  5. Decide the repeat rule. When a customer from last year's LSA lead calls back, is it LSA or repeat? Either answer works. Changing it month to month does not.
  6. Check the unknowns weekly. Ten minutes on Friday fixing untagged jobs saves a quarter of bad decisions.

Mistakes that make the numbers lie

Ad spend and platform fees are usually deductible business expenses, but how you record them matters at tax time. Keep each source's charges separate in your books and confirm the treatment with your accountant.

What to do Monday morning

How ServiceBuilt handles it

ServiceBuilt's marketing hub puts leads from Google LSA, Thumbtack, Angi, Facebook and Instagram, your website and Riley, the AI receptionist, into one inbox, sends new leads a speed-to-lead text from your own number, and reports revenue, cost per booked job and ROAS by lead source. Every booked job stays on the customer record in the ServiceBuilt CRM, with full job history, memberships and review requests, so repeat work gets worked instead of bought again. The marketing hub, call tracking and ROI attribution are on the Powerhouse plan.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best lead source for a garage door company?

There is no single best source for every market. The best one for your shop is the source with the highest gross profit per dollar spent over the last few months, measured from booked and completed jobs, not from leads. Your market, your phones and your job mix all change the answer, so let your own numbers decide before you move budget.

How do I calculate cost per booked job?

Take what you spent on a source for the month, including platform fees and any agency or software cost tied to it, and divide by the number of jobs from that source that actually got booked. A source that cost $1,500 and booked 18 jobs cost about $83 per booked job, no matter how cheap each lead looked.

How does Google Local Services Ads charge garage door companies?

Google says Local Services Ads charge for valid leads rather than clicks, and that leads such as answered calls, qualifying missed calls, messages, voicemails and booking requests can be charged. Charged leads judged low quality later can be credited automatically. Google is also moving these ads into Performance Max campaigns with pay-per-lead goals in phases, so check Google's help center for how it applies to your account.

Should I stop paying for Thumbtack or Angi leads?

Not on a hunch. Track every job from each source for at least two or three months, then compare cost per booked job and profit after ad spend. If a source books few jobs or only small tickets, cut its budget first rather than switching it off, and watch whether the jobs move to another source.