Pay on gross profit — the ticket minus what the parts cost you — at a higher percentage than you would use on revenue. Revenue commission overpays on parts-heavy jobs like openers and new doors and underpays on labor-heavy repair work. Profit commission pays for the work and the sale, not for the price of the door.
Why revenue commission leaks on garage door jobs
A garage door ticket is not one kind of job. An adjustment is almost all labor. A spring swap is mostly labor with a modest part. An opener install carries a real unit cost. A new door is mostly door. When every one of those pays the same percentage of the ticket, the tech earns commission on the money you hand straight back to the distributor.
Nobody notices on any one job. You notice at the end of the year, when installs were your busiest category and somehow your thinnest margin.
The math on four common jobs
Same tech, same week, four jobs. Revenue basis at 20% of the ticket, profit basis at 30% of the ticket minus parts cost.
| Job | Ticket | Parts cost | 20% of revenue | 30% of profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adjustment and tune-up | $250 | $10 | $50 | $72 |
| Torsion spring replacement | $450 | $90 | $90 | $108 |
| Rebuild package | $1,100 | $380 | $220 | $216 |
| New door install | $2,800 | $1,600 | $560 | $360 |
| Week total | $4,600 | $2,080 | $920 | $756 |
Illustrative numbers, not a pay recommendation. Plug in your own tickets and costs.
Look at where the money moves. On the labor jobs the profit basis actually pays the tech more. On the rebuild it is a wash. The whole difference comes from the door install, where revenue commission paid $200 on the door's cost. That is the leak, and it grows with every install you sell.
What profit commission gets right
- It rewards the work. A tech who fixes three doors well earns more than one who drops off one expensive unit.
- It keeps installs profitable. Your margin on a door no longer depends on how much of it you paid out as commission.
- It makes discounting the tech's problem too. On revenue, a $100 discount costs the tech $20. On profit, it comes straight out of the profit they are paid on, so they think twice before giving the store away.
- It survives price increases. When a manufacturer raises door prices, your margin stays protected because the cost comes off first.
The traps when you switch
Stale part costs
Profit commission is only as honest as the costs in your price book. If a spring's cost is from two years ago, every spring pays the wrong commission. Update costs when your distributor's prices change, and decide what happens when a job has no cost on it at all — paying on a guess is how trust breaks.
Setting the percentage by feel
Don't pick the new percentage out of the air. Take last quarter's actual jobs for each tech, run them through both bases, and choose the profit percentage that keeps a good tech's weekly pay where it was on a normal mix. Show them the side-by-side before you change anything.
Forgetting hourly and overtime rules
Commission does not switch off wage law. Most commissioned field techs are still owed at least minimum wage and overtime for hours over 40 in a week under federal law, and some states add more. Have your accountant or a labor attorney look at the plan before it goes live.
Changing it mid-week
Switch at the start of a pay period, in writing, with the math from their own jobs. Techs accept a new plan they can check; they fight one they can't.
Mixed plans that work
Not every tech should be on straight commission. A newer tech still learning is often better on hourly, or hourly plus a smaller profit percentage, so a slow week doesn't punish them for the board. An installer on big jobs may suit a different percentage than a service tech. The basis — profit, not revenue — can stay the same across all of them.
How ServiceBuilt handles it
We built this into ServiceBuilt payroll because we paid revenue commission ourselves before we caught the leak. Commission is figured on gross profit, with material cost taken off before the percentage, and you set the basis once for every payroll run. Each tech can be on hourly, commission, or a base plus a percentage, and anyone without a pay type inherits the company default instead of being paid nothing. When a job has no part cost recorded, its commission is held and the job is listed instead of being paid on a guess. Timesheets, overtime and the weekly per-tech breakdown sit underneath, so you see the number before you pay it.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage commission do garage door technicians get?
There is no single industry rate. Shops that pay on revenue often land somewhere in the high teens to mid twenties percent; shops that pay on gross profit use a higher percentage because the base is smaller. The right number is the one that pays a good tech a competitive weekly wage on your actual job mix while leaving the margin you need, so run last quarter's jobs through both bases before you pick.
Should garage door techs be paid on profit or revenue?
Profit, for most garage door shops. Garage door tickets mix labor-heavy work like adjustments and spring swaps with parts-heavy work like openers and new doors. A revenue percentage pays the tech for the cost of the door; a profit percentage pays them for the work and the sale, and stops you losing money on installs.
What counts as cost when paying commission on profit?
Usually the material cost of the parts on the invoice at what you paid for them. Some shops also take out a fixed trip or overhead charge. Whatever you choose, write it down, apply it to every job the same way, and keep the price book costs current, because a stale part cost silently changes everyone's pay.
Do commissioned garage door techs still get overtime?
Often yes. Under federal law most commissioned field technicians are still non-exempt and owed at least minimum wage and overtime for hours over 40 in a week, and state rules can add more. Check your plan with your accountant or a labor attorney before you roll it out.
